# Answer key · BK01

## Did clients subscribe more often after an earlier campaign succeeded?

Marketing teams decide whom to call again. If clients who said yes before say yes again far more often, that changes who goes on the list, but only if the comparison is read the right way round.

- One record is — one client campaign record (repeated contacts can contribute to the same record)
- Period — May 2008 – November 2010
- Scope — Selected telephone marketing campaign records from one Portuguese bank.

## The table

Current campaign × Earlier campaign outcome

| Current campaign | Prior success | Prior failure | No prior outcome |
| --- | ---: | ---: | ---: |
| Subscribed | 894 | 605 | 3,141 |
| Did not subscribe | 479 | 3,647 | 32,422 |

## Which comparison shows whether clients subscribed more often after an earlier campaign succeeded?

1. Compare the number of subscribers under each earlier outcome.
2. Compare what share of all subscribers came from each earlier outcome.
3. Compare the subscription share within Prior success and within Prior failure, each out of its own records.

Choose one statement. Show the counts and denominators that justify it, then describe one limit of the comparison.

## The figures behind the check

- **1. Not supported.** Counts follow group size. No prior outcome has by far the most subscribers, 3,141, because it holds 35,563 records; its subscription share is the lowest of the three, 8.8%.
- **2. Not supported.** That divides by the 4,640 subscribers, so it says where subscribers came from: 67.7% from No prior outcome and 19.3% from Prior success. It does not say how often each group subscribed.
- **3. Supported.** 894 of 1,373 (65.1%) against 605 of 4,252 (14.2%), a gap of 50.9 percentage points. Those are the two groups the question names; No prior outcome is reported beside them, not merged into either.

- Prior success: 894 of 1,373 subscribed (65.1%).
- Prior failure: 605 of 4,252 subscribed (14.2%).
- No prior outcome: 3,141 of 35,563 subscribed (8.8%); kept outside the two-group comparison.

Name both groups and both bases when you quote this gap: Prior success against Prior failure. Comparing Prior success with all other records would fold in No prior outcome and answer a different question.

## Limits

Selected campaign records from one bank. The bank chose whom to contact and how often, so the comparison cannot say what would happen if everyone were called again.

## Source

Data: Sérgio Moro, Paulo Rita and Paulo Cortez (2014). Bank Marketing. UCI Machine Learning Repository. DOI 10.24432/C5K306. Licensed under [CC BY 4.0](https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/). Crosstabs selected, recoded and aggregated the records into this table.

- [Sérgio Moro, Paulo Rita and Paulo Cortez (2014). Bank Marketing. UCI Machine Learning Repository. DOI 10.24432/C5K306.](https://archive.ics.uci.edu/dataset/222/bank+marketing)
- [Reproduce it · BK01](https://www.crosstabs.com/examples/bk01-how-did-term-deposit-subscription-vary-with-the-earlier-campaign-outcome)
- [CSV](https://www.crosstabs.com/examples/bk01-how-did-term-deposit-subscription-vary-with-the-earlier-campaign-outcome/download/csv) · [JSON](https://www.crosstabs.com/examples/bk01-how-did-term-deposit-subscription-vary-with-the-earlier-campaign-outcome/download/json)
